Skip to Content

Can pain sensitivity and affect-related behavior be modulated separately?

Nature communications · 2023-04-17

Table of contents

No titles in the blog post

Nature Communications · Research frontiers

Can pain sensitivity and affect-related behavior be modulated separately?

Pain sensitivity and negative behavioral measures can coexist without changing together. In male mice, ventral pallidal cholinergic cells and their amygdala projection influence these measures on different time scales.

Original Figure 2b detail: merged fluorescence associated with ventral pallidal cholinergic cells

Persistent pain can accompany less exploration and greater immobility in selected tasks. Do sensitization and these behavioral changes depend on identical brain processes? A study published in Nature Communications on April 17, 2023 examined ventral pallidal, VP, cholinergic cells and their projection to the basolateral amygdala, BLA, in male mice. Acute manipulation altered mechanical and thermal responses. After repeated modulation, selected affect-related behavioral changes outlasted stimulation, whereas sensitization did not show the same persistent change.

KEY FINDING

VP cholinergic circuitry becomes more active in persistent-pain models. Acute suppression attenuates sensitization, while repeated suppression improves selected pain-associated anxiety- and depression-like measures. Sensitization was not significantly reduced after repeated suppression ended, revealing distinct temporal scopes.

Contents · 7 sections

VP cells become more excitable alongside sensitization

Peripheral nerve injury lowered mechanical withdrawal thresholds and shortened heat-withdrawal latency for weeks. Activity-related labeling increased bilaterally in VP, including both choline acetyltransferase, ChAT, cells and non-ChAT cells. Both populations showed greater evoked firing under matched current input.

Evoked acetylcholine release was also enhanced after injury. Blocking nicotinic acetylcholine receptors reduced excessive non-ChAT activity, linking cholinergic signaling with neighboring cells in the subcortical adaptation associated with persistent sensitization.

Original figure 3VP activity after nerve injury
VP activity after nerve injury
Figure 3 shows increased bilateral activity labeling and evoked firing in ChAT and non-ChAT cells. Related acetylcholine-release comparisons appear in the original supplementary material.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

Activating cholinergic cells increases bilateral sensitivity

In uninjured mice, activating ChAT cells in one VP lowered mechanical thresholds and shortened heat-withdrawal latency in both hind paws. Measures returned toward their previous levels after stimulation, linking cellular activity with immediate, reversible nociceptive responses.

Local pharmacological comparisons likewise linked enhanced acetylcholine signaling with increased mechanical sensitivity and showed attenuation by nicotinic-receptor blockade. The direction of cholinergic pain modulation therefore depends on its regional context.

Original figure 4Mechanical and thermal responses during acute activation
Mechanical and thermal responses during acute activation
Figure 4 shows bilateral hind-paw changes during unilateral VP-cell activation and their reversal afterward, without the same significant changes in fluorescent controls.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

Repeated activation leaves behavioral changes without persistent sensitization

Injured mice showed increased tail-suspension and swimming immobility and reduced exposed-space exploration. Repeated VP cholinergic activation in uninjured mice produced selected behavioral changes in similar directions after stimulation ended, alongside persistent activity-marker increases.

Several days after stimulation ended, mechanical thresholds, thermal responses and locomotor measures did not differ significantly. Affective-task changes thus separated temporally from acute sensitization, showing that one population can influence distinct outcomes without making all measures persistently shift together.

Original figure 5Behavior and VP activity after repeated activation
Behavior and VP activity after repeated activation
Figure 5 shows persistent-pain behaviors and effects of repeated cellular activation. Supplementary comparisons report no significant post-stimulation sensitization or locomotor change.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

Suppressing activity raises response thresholds in pain states

Acute VP cholinergic suppression raised mechanical thresholds and lengthened heat-withdrawal latency in inflammatory and nerve-injury pain models. Corresponding measures in uninjured mice did not change significantly, indicating a different functional contribution in sensitized states.

Activity labeling decreased with suppression, including changes in local non-ChAT cells. These findings do not restrict every effect to direct monosynaptic connections; contributions of local networks and distant outputs remain to be resolved.

Original figure 6Acute suppression in pain models
Acute suppression in pain models
Figure 6 shows nociceptive responses and VP activity in pain models. Cell-body suppression has a different scope from the terminal-field comparisons below.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

Selected behavioral improvements outlast repeated suppression

After nerve injury, repeated suppression reduced tail-suspension and swimming immobility and increased open-arm time and entries after suppression ended. Corresponding travel distance did not change significantly, while VP activity labeling remained lower.

The benefit had contextual limits. Sensitization measured after suppression ended was not significantly reduced, and comparable suppression did not improve tested anxiety- or depression-like measures in two chronic-stress models. The findings therefore point to a pain-associated contribution rather than a universal affective effect.

Original figure 7Repeated suppression and behavior after injury
Repeated suppression and behavior after injury
Figure 7 shows selected behavioral improvements and lower activity labeling after injury, without significant travel-distance changes.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

An amygdala projection reveals clearer laterality

VP cholinergic cells project densely to BLA. Activating their terminals in one BLA altered mechanical and thermal responses in the contralateral hind paw without significant ipsilateral changes. This differs from bilateral effects of VP cell-body activation, revealing separable scopes of local and distant contributions.

Repeated bilateral terminal activation also changed selected affect-related behaviors after stimulation ended, without significant changes in tested sensitization or locomotion. BLA cellular responses remained heterogeneous: some cells were excited, others inhibited or weakly responsive.

Original figure 9Laterality and timing of the VP–BLA connection
Laterality and timing of the VP–BLA connection
Figure 9 shows contralateral hind-paw effects of unilateral terminal activation and behavioral changes after repeated bilateral activation, separating acute from post-stimulation testing.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

Sensitization and affect-related improvement need not share one time course

In pain models, acute VP–BLA terminal suppression attenuated contralateral sensitization, whereas repeated bilateral suppression improved selected anxiety- and depression-like measures after stimulation ended. Post-suppression sensitization did not improve significantly, demonstrating state- and time-dependent contributions.

These male-mouse findings sharpen the relationship between sensitization and negative behavioral measures. Which downstream cells mediate each effect, how local and distant outputs interact, and whether findings extend to females or humans remain unresolved. They identify circuit nodes for investigation without establishing clinical efficacy.

Original figure 10Acute and later behavioral effects of terminal suppression
Acute and later behavioral effects of terminal suppression
Figure 10 shows distinct acute and repeated-suppression effects: sensitization improvement is limited to the corresponding acute contralateral comparisons, whereas selected later affect-related improvements follow repeated modulation.
Source: Ji YW et al. · Nature communications · CC BY
Original figure and English caption ↗

Publication details

Ji YW, Shen ZL, Zhang X, Zhang K, Jia T, Xu X, Geng H, Han Y, Yin C, Yang JJ, Yang JJ, Cao JL, Zhou C, Xiao C.
Plasticity in ventral pallidal cholinergic neuron-derived circuits contributes to comorbid chronic pain-like and depression-like behaviour in male mice
Nature communications · 2023-04-17
DOI: 10.1038/s41467-023-37968-x